TheCommentAnalyst

[elixir]

Has anyone come across this channel on YouTube? It is a really strange idea. It's not really a series, but does have it's own channel. It's just all backwards with 6 subscribers, and 644 subscriptions, and its profile says they've only watched 25 videos.

This is the summary on their YouTube channel:

"The comment analyst believes that youtuber's comments are an important but undervalued aspect of youtube. Subsequently the comment analyst subscribes to youtubers who have made a interesting/entertaining/origi nal comment.

The comment analyst subscribes irregardless of the youtuber's videos or popularity. The comment analyst understands that its view is subjective. It also wishes to clarify that it works independently of youtube. The comment analyst is unable to discuss comments with its subscriptions."

"Irregardless," I fail to see the point of it all. They have no videos, so they don't seem to be trying to get views...

www.youtube.com/profile?user=TheCommentAnalyst

[milowent]

what a wacky idea. reminds me a bit of the watchman, who used to make videos trashing haterz comments:

www.youtube.com/profile?user=watchman55

[elixir]

The Watchman is hillarious!

I can understand him though. He actually makes videos. He actually entertains.

This CommentAnalyst doesn't seem to do anything but compile a list of people who they think write 'good' comments. It's just weird, because there is no way to see people's comments on other videos unless you just so happen to come across it yourself. It seems pointless. It would be much better if they actually made some videos like the Watchman, where they go through the comments.

I was just wondering if they had subscribed to anyone's channel here. They subscribed to mine, even though I have no videos. Considering their profile says they've watched only 25 videos, I was wondering if they had maybe just subscribed to people who had commented on a popular video, like a Lonelygirl15 one.

And if so why? Why? Are they going to try to sell our souls or something??!